I do not usually east hot spicy foods but this sauce is spicy in a good way with an after taste that makes you come back for more. Naive and filled with machismo, I dunked a chilled shrimp into the cocktail sauce, scooping out a good tablespoon’s worth, and like a moron inserted it whole into my gaping maw. It always amazes my friends who have never tried it before. We really should talk about St. Elmo Steak House. But, I’m warning you: go easy on the first bite. Remember that time you asked us, or one of our com. Soooo Good! The restaurant achieved pop cultural notoriety in 2013 when the show Parks & Recreation filmed on location, during which Newt Gingrich just happened to dine at the restaurant and the former Speaker of the House was worked into the episode. Get all of the famous flavors of St. Elmo Steak House in one box. ITS HOT so do not buy it and them give them a 1 star review because its hot. Legendary really is the right adjective—it’s been serving steaks and seafood in downtown Indianapolis since 1902, and was was named an “America’s Classic” by the James Beard Foundation in 2012. The only thing I miss are the nice people and St. Elmos Cocktail Sauce. ITS HOT so do not buy it and them give them a 1 star review because its hot. serving steaks and seafood in downtown Indianapolis. My sister coughed on the first bite. Ingredients Your First Bag Free + up to $55 off Gift Subscriptions. As if you needed a reason to order Chef Jeremy’s. Servings: About 2 cups of cocktail sauce. LEARN MORE. A Pacers fan named Eric managed to down an entire order of St. Elmo shrimp cocktail in 13 goddamn seconds and managed to not die immediately. This recipe was a major victory by his standards. This stuff is not for the palate-challenged. St. Elmo shrimp cocktail sauce, with its nuclear-grade horseradish, was at least five times as potent. When I was in high school, a “friend” hid a glob of wasabi into guacamole as a joke. The Inventory team is rounding up deals you don’t want to miss, now through Cyber Monday. It always amazes my friends who have never tried it before. The only thing I miss are the nice people and St. Elmos Cocktail Sauce. Click here to browse! Dry-aged for 60 days before grilling to perfection . Mar 10, 2014 - Recipe for St Elmo's Cocktail Sauce! St. Elmo’s (almost) Cocktail Sauce. And he did it less than one-third of the 45 seconds allotted, a feat as impressive as running a sub-hour marathon.For stepping to the precipice of the hereafter, Eric was awarded a $75 gift certificate—presumably to St. Elmo Steak House—and immortality in The Takeout’s Hall of Champions. That’s the goal, people. ! I couldn’t even muster any words, just the noise of guttural intakes of air—guuuhhhhhhhh guuuhhhhhh—as my face disintegrated into ash. ENJOY ST. ELMO AT HOME. Have our world famous St. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail and Steaks delivered right to your home for you to prepare. Go s great with everything Read more. Naive and filled with machismo, I dunked a chilled shrimp into the cocktail sauce, scooping out a good tablespoon’s worth, and like a moron inserted it whole into my gaping maw. Last night we held our annual Years of Service din. Kevin Pang was the founding editor of The Takeout, and director of the documentary For Grace. Going to St. Elmo’s is the one reason I have for wanting to visit Indianapolis. World Famous St. Elmo Cocktail Sauce™ St. Elmo Seasoning Izzy's Sauce I do not usually east hot spicy foods but this sauce is spicy in a good way with an after taste that makes you come back for more. The first time a friend foisted a bottle of shrimp cocktail sauce from Indianapolis’ legendary St. Elmo Steak House, I did not realize the specter of death that lied within. I saw Ray Lampe, Dr. BBQ, select this as his favorite Hot & Spicy Food on that episode of BEST THING I EVER ATE and it looked terrifying and delicious as I love horseradish. Our world famous spicy cocktail sauce, steak sauce and seasoning to complement steaks, burgers, and chops, and our creamy horseradish to add tons of flavor to sandwiches, prime-rib, and more. The first time a friend foisted a bottle of shrimp cocktail sauce from Indianapolis’ legendary St. Elmo Steak House, I did not realize the specter of death that lied within. In that context, watching this video from Wednesday night’s Indiana Pacers game was one of the most awe-inspiring clips I’ve ever witnessed. This cocktail sauce is what a champion eats.