St. Elmo Steak House. It offers a refreshing balance of crisp cola and smooth bourbon. Click here to send them information about St. Elmo Foods. Although it is an infused whiskey, at 88 proof it is a robust spirit that blends perfectly in cocktails. DON’T SEE YOUR FAVORITE RETAILER? The signature St. Elmo Steak House cocktail, the Elmo Cola, now in a can. It is often served on the rocks with a dash of bitters for a Manhattan or the way we serve it in St. Elmo Steak House with a splash of cola to recreate our signature Elmo Cola. We start with our very own Straight Bourbon Whiskey with Dark Cherry and Bourbon Vanilla Beans, then finish by mixing with cola. St. Elmo's Straight Bourbon Whiskey is 88 proof, made with dark cherry, bourbon vanilla beans, and can be bought from many local retailers. Guests can now enjoy a taste of St. Elmo Steak House cocktails at home with the launch of the restaurant’s ready-to-drink Elmo Cola in a can. World Famous St. Elmo Cocktail Sauce™ St. Elmo Seasoning Izzy's Sauce As the restaurant’s top-selling signature cocktail, the Elmo Cola combines the restaurant’s own dark cherry and vanilla bourbon with cola. But a rather simple cocktail has given the iconic restaurant a new claim to fame. Comprising two ounces of bourbon infused with vanilla beans, whole cherries and cherry juice, the drink is topped with Coca-Cola and served over ice in a large tumbler with a cherry garnish. The legendary St. Elmo Steak House has been an Indianapolis institution for more than a century and is regularly listed among the best steak houses in the country. 46225 (317) 635-0636 127 S. Illinois St. Indianapolis, IN. In the past few months, however, the Elmo Cola, a highball first served at the historic St. Elmo Steak House in Indianapolis, has taken the state by storm. Indy's own St. Elmo recently released it's own bottled bourbon whiskey that serves as the foundation of the famous Elmo Cola drink.